The used shotgun market has plenty of options, but experienced buyers often pay closer attention to certain models than others. Some have earned a reputation through decades of dependable service, while others stand out for their craftsmanship, handling, or distinctive designs. Older shotguns can also offer features and build quality that are harder to find in similarly priced new models. However, condition, maintenance history, parts availability, and previous use matter just as much as the name stamped on the receiver. These five shotguns continue to attract attention from buyers who appreciate established designs and lasting value.
1. Remington Model 870 Wingmaster
Introduced in 1950, the Remington Model 870 became one of the best-known pump-action shotguns, with more than 10 million produced. Used buyers often focus on the Wingmaster, its better-finished traditional version, known for polished metalwork and walnut furniture. The model appeared in several gauges and configurations, making the exact variant important. Older examples can show wear around the wood, finish, and moving parts. Check the serial and model markings, barrel condition, and maintenance history. A qualified gunsmith should inspect any prospective purchase. Its long production history also makes service information and replacement parts comparatively familiar to experienced owners.
2. Mossberg 500
Mossberg introduced the Model 500 in 1961, and its practical design helped establish it as a familiar name in the pump-action market. Used examples attract attention because the family includes numerous field and sporting configurations, with differences in gauge, stock material, and barrel specifications. That variety makes careful identification important, as two Model 500 shotguns may have different features and intended uses. Buyers should examine the receiver and barrel markings, check for corrosion or visible damage, and confirm the original configuration. A documented service history and inspection by a qualified gunsmith are more valuable than cosmetic upgrades or a seller’s claim that the shotgun is barely used.
3. Winchester Model 12
The Winchester Model 12 arrived in 1912 and became a landmark pump-action design, earning the nickname Perfect Repeater. Its steel construction, classic appearance, and association with generations of American sportsmen keep it popular among collectors and traditional shotgun enthusiasts. Production ended in 1964, making every used example an older firearm that deserves careful examination. Variants differ in gauge, barrel configuration, and grade, while some have undergone modifications over the decades. Original finish and matching components can influence collector interest. Before purchasing, have a gunsmith assess its overall condition, barrel, and stock. A well-preserved example with documented history is particularly appealing to collectors.
4. Browning Citori
Browning introduced the Citori in 1971 as an over-and-under shotgun featuring a strong steel receiver and carefully fitted components. It became popular with hunters and clay-target shooters who appreciate its balance, finish, and traditional two-barrel design. The Citori name covers numerous grades and configurations, ranging from practical field models to elaborate sporting versions. Consequently, used prices can vary considerably. Buyers often consider older examples because of their established craftsmanship and traditional styling. Check the model markings, wood condition, and exterior finish, and arrange a professional mechanical inspection. Browning’s long-standing attention to component fitting remains an important part of the Citori’s reputation.
5. Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon
Beretta’s 686 family, including the Silver Pigeon line, is a familiar name in the over-and-under shotgun category. Its appeal comes from Italian manufacturing, traditional styling, and popularity in both field and clay-target settings. The 686 family includes several generations and versions, with differences in engraving, stock dimensions, barrel lengths, and overall finish. This makes checking the exact model particularly important when considering a used example. Buyers should look for neglected woodwork, corrosion, damaged finishes and evidence of poor repairs. A qualified gunsmith should inspect its condition before purchase. A well-maintained example with a clear ownership and service history is generally more attractive than one with unnecessary modifications.
