Stunning 1921 Stone Hunting Lodge in Pocono Pines, Pennsylvania with 200 Feet of Lakefront and a Covered Wraparound Porch

Daniel Whitaker

|

January 17, 2026

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The Blair House, a stunning 1921 stone hunting lodge located at 5202 Woodland Avenue, Pocono Pines, PA, is a rare lakefront treasure on Lake Naomi, showcasing rich historical significance and timeless character. This architectural gem spans 3,941 square feet and boasts 5 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, all set on a generous wooded lot featuring 200 feet of lakefront. Its original stonework and spacious layout invite creativity, while a covered wraparound porch provides an idyllic space for gatherings. Priced at $1,800,000, the home—sold AS IS—offers the opportunity for renovations to breathe new life into its storied design, surrounded by the natural beauty of the Pocono Mountains.

Lakeside Retreat

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

A serene lakeside area features two sun loungers positioned on a grassy patch, inviting relaxation. Surrounding tall trees create a natural frame, providing shade and privacy. The lush greenery contrasts beautifully with the shimmering water of the lake, which reflects a bright blue sky dotted with fluffy white clouds. The scene is tranquil, enhanced by gentle ripples on the lake’s surface, suggesting a gentle breeze. This outdoor space combines a rustic charm with a peaceful ambiance, perfect for unwinding or enjoying nature. The arrangement emphasizes a harmonious blend of landscape and leisure, ideal for quiet moments by the water.

Exterior View

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The image showcases a historic American house nestled among tall trees, displaying robust stonework at its base, providing a rustic charm. The upper section features a combination of wood and a distinct red gabled roof, enhancing the architectural character. A spacious porch with wooden railings offers an inviting touch, surrounded by lush greenery and ferns that frame the property beautifully. The layout reveals arched openings beneath the porch, adding a unique design element that speaks to the craftsmanship of its era. The interplay of natural light and the surrounding forest enhances the home’s serene and picturesque ambiance.

Home Exterior

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The facade of a historic American home blends beautifully with its natural surroundings. Crafted from stone, the exterior features large, arched windows that invite ample natural light. A prominent porch lined with sturdy columns offers a welcoming entrance, complemented by a subtle roofline that hints at a rustic charm. The color palette includes earthy tones, harmonizing with the lush greenery of the surrounding trees. The landscape reveals scattered leaves, adding a touch of autumnal warmth. The stone base provides texture, while the upper sections showcase traditional architectural elements, creating an inviting, timeless aesthetic.

House Exterior

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The image showcases a historic home exterior featuring a combination of stone and wood elements. The lower level is clad in irregularly shaped stones, adding rustic charm, while the upper part displays a deep red wooden siding. Tall, narrow windows punctuate the stone facade, offering a glimpse of the interior. A covered porch with sturdy white columns provides an inviting entry point, decorated with an American flag hanging gently. A stone pathway leads toward the entrance, bordered by lush greenery and tall trees, enhancing the natural aesthetic and tranquil atmosphere of the surrounding landscape.

Exterior View

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The image presents a charming exterior of a historic American home nestled amidst lush greenery. The structure features a mix of stone and wood materials, with a broad stone foundation supporting a large, overhanging porch. This porch is bordered by robust pillars, creating an inviting entrance. The roof showcases a gentle slope, adorned with a rich, reddish-brown hue that complements the earthy tones of the stone facade. Expansive windows allow natural light to flow in, while the surrounding ferns and tall trees enhance the serene, nature-inspired aesthetic of the property. The overall design harmonizes with its woodland setting.

Exterior View

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

A charming two-story stone house nestled amid towering trees creates a rustic appeal. The facade features large windows that reflect natural light, enhancing the earthy tones of the stonework. A welcoming front porch with steps leads to a small entrance door, adorned with a red accent that adds vibrancy to the neutral tones of the stone. Surrounding the home, lush green ground cover provides a soft contrast against the rugged exterior. Shafts of sunlight filter through the trees, casting delicate shadows that accentuate the serenity of the setting, suggesting a tranquil woodland retreat.

Front Entrance

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The front entrance showcases a charming stone facade, harmonizing with the surrounding trees. A cozy wooden staircase leads to double doors, accentuating a welcoming ambiance. The roof features a captivating red hue, contrasting with the natural tones of the stone and earthy greens of ferns. Large windows flanking the entrance allow ample light, revealing the inviting interior. The porch extends slightly, supported by sturdy stone columns, adding to the rustic charm. Tall trees frame the scene, enhancing privacy while contributing to the serene, woodland setting. The overall aesthetic blends nature with historic architecture, creating a tranquil retreat.

Front Porch

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

A spacious front porch features natural stone walls providing rustic charm. The flooring is designed with a warm, earthy tone, complementing the stonework. Comfortable wooden furniture includes several rocking chairs adorned with colorful floral cushions, inviting relaxation. A wooden table set for outdoor dining enhances the functionality of the space, surrounded by trees that offer a serene view. The ceiling boasts a light fixture, ensuring the area is well-lit. Soft, natural hues accentuate the overall aesthetic, creating a welcoming atmosphere that blends seamlessly with the surrounding nature, perfect for leisurely afternoons.

Front Porch

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

A charming front porch features natural stone walls that provide a rustic charm. The ceiling showcases a smooth wooden finish, creating a warm ambiance. Minimalist white furniture, including two simple chairs and a table, invites relaxation and conversation. A wooden bench with blue and white striped cushions offers additional seating. Sunlight streams through large windows, illuminating the space and highlighting the intricate lace curtains. The surrounding greenery is visible through the openings, enhancing the connection with nature. The floor is made of polished wood, further contributing to the cozy, welcoming atmosphere of this historic home.

Front Porch

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This inviting front porch features a rustic stone wall that complements the natural surroundings. The floor is a warm wood finish, enhancing the cozy ambiance. A pair of vintage, floral-patterned sofas offer comfortable seating, accented by green metal frames. A simple wooden coffee table sits at the center, providing a perfect space for refreshments. To the side, a classic wooden trunk adds a touch of nostalgia. Large windows allow sunlight to filter through while showcasing the lush greenery outside, creating a serene atmosphere. The overall design harmonizes rustic charm with a welcoming, relaxed vibe.

Lakefront View

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The view presents a serene lakeside scene with lush greenery surrounding the water’s edge. Tall trees frame the left side, their leaves a vibrant green, creating a tranquil atmosphere. The grassy area leading to the lake is well-kept, with patches of wild grass and subtle earth tones. In the background, the calm water reflects the bright blue sky, dotted with fluffy white clouds. A solitary rock sits partially submerged in the water, adding a natural focal point. The scene exudes a peaceful, outdoor ambiance ideal for relaxation or contemplation, showcasing the beauty of nature.

Entrance Porch

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The entrance porch features a rustic stone exterior highlighting an array of varied earth tones. Large double doors with white frames open towards an inviting interior, revealing glimpses of a cozy living space beyond. Simple, vintage fixtures are mounted beside the doors, enhancing the home’s charm. A woven bench adorned with a floral cushion provides a soft spot for relaxation. The wooden flooring complements the overall warmth of the space, while the overhead structure showcases a smooth, light-colored ceiling. Natural light filters through the windows, further emphasizing the porch’s welcoming and serene atmosphere.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The space features an open layout with rustic wooden flooring that enhances the historical charm. Natural light streams through large windows dressed with lace curtains, illuminating the room. A vintage wooden door leads to an outdoor space, while period-appropriate furniture, including an ornate wooden chest and a simple chair, complements the aesthetic. The walls are painted a soft white, providing a clean backdrop for the rich tones of the furniture. A classic radiator adds warmth, and the overall design evokes a sense of cozy nostalgia, ideal for relaxation and connection with nature.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This cozy living room features a rustic stone fireplace as its focal point, surrounded by light-colored walls that complement the wooden flooring. A woven chaise lounge adds a touch of vintage charm, while a wooden console table showcases stacked books, creating an inviting atmosphere. Large windows allow natural light to filter in, illuminating the space. The warm wooden accents in the doors and trim contrast beautifully with the neutral tones of the room. Overall, the layout is open, encouraging a relaxed social environment, enhanced by vintage decor and a sense of history.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The living room showcases a blend of vintage charm and rustic elements. The hardwood floor features varying shades, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. A vibrant yellow settee serves as a bold focal point, complemented by dark wood furniture, including a chest and a dresser. Natural light pours in through the large windows adorned with lace curtains, adding to the room’s airy feel. The walls are painted in a soft, neutral tone, enhancing the warmth of the wood. Decorative accents like framed pictures and a vintage lamp contribute to the nostalgic ambiance, reflecting the home’s historic character.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This cozy living room features a rustic stone fireplace as its focal point, showcasing a charming painting above. The room’s natural wood elements complement the warm color palette, highlighted by the rich hues of the hardwood floor. A woven seating area offers comfort, while a vintage side chair adds elegance. On one side, a small wooden table with stacked papers hints at a space for reading or reminiscing. The decor blends traditional craftsmanship with a homely ambiance, enhanced by wall sconces that provide soft lighting, all creating a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This living room features warm wooden flooring, showcasing its aged beauty. The space is illuminated by natural light spilling in from large windows, which highlight the high ceilings. A vintage wicker chaise lounge sits prominently, adding a touch of nostalgia. Dark wooden furniture pieces, including a sideboard and a dining table with ornate legs, cover the room, contrasting with the light walls. A staircase with elegant wooden railings ascends in the background, drawing the eye upward, while scattered photographs and books evoke a sense of personal history, making this room feel both inviting and reflective.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The living room features warm, rustic aesthetics with wide, polished wooden floorboards adding character. A mix of vintage and contemporary furniture defines the space; a striking orange chair contrasts with a dark wooden chest and a tall, elegant black cabinet. Natural light filters in through multiple windows adorned with simple lace curtains, creating a soft glow. Architectural details include wooden moldings and a prominent staircase in the background, showcasing period craftsmanship. The overall color palette leans toward earthy tones, complemented by the greenery visible through the doors, evoking a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The living room features a rustic charm with warm wooden flooring and a series of vintage furnishings. A dark wooden sideboard stands against the wall, complemented by ornate wall sconces that add a touch of elegance. A sleek mid-century modern chair in bright orange creates a vivid focal point. To the right, a door leads to another room filled with natural light from large windows. The walls are painted in a soft, neutral hue, enhancing the room’s spaciousness and allowing the rich wooden elements to stand out. The overall aesthetic blends vintage charm with modern comfort.

Entry Hall

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The entry hall features a warm wood staircase leading to an upper level, with wooden railings that add a classic touch. To the left, stylish glass-paneled doors are framed by traditional molding, inviting natural light. The space boasts rustic wooden flooring, showcasing character with its worn texture. An antique cabinet sits against the wall, adding elegance. A vintage chair is positioned nearby, complementing the aesthetic with its intricate design. The walls, painted in a soft, neutral hue, enhance the room’s brightness, while the high ceiling contributes to an open, airy atmosphere, offering a glimpse into the home’s rich history.

Kitchen

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This kitchen showcases rustic charm with a blend of modern functionality. Dark wood cabinetry complements the light brown hardwood floors, while white walls enhance the airy feel. The countertop features a contrasting black surface, providing a stylish workspace. A stainless steel gas stove adds a contemporary touch amidst traditional elements. Colorful glass decor hangs in the windows, inviting natural light, while the patterned red backsplash brings warmth and vibrancy. In the background, a small sink area and a glimpse of a bathroom highlight the practical design, ensuring an efficient and cozy cooking environment.

Kitchen

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This historic kitchen features rich wooden cabinetry with intricate detailing, contrasting beautifully against a vibrant red tiled backsplash that showcases a classic diamond pattern. The black countertops offer a sleek surface, while a modern dishwasher blends into the cabinetry. Natural light pours through the window, highlighting glass jars of various colors on the sill. Open shelving displays assorted dishware, contributing to the eclectic decor. The flooring consists of warm, honey-toned hardwood, adding an inviting feel to the space. A vintage light fixture hangs above, further enhancing the room’s charm and character.

Kitchen

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The kitchen showcases a rustic design with ample wooden cabinetry, featuring a rich golden oak finish. The layout includes a refrigerator and a washer, juxtaposed against a black countertop that offers a striking contrast. Natural light filters through a large window, illuminating the space while highlighting the textured wooden floors. Open shelving provides a practical touch for displaying kitchen essentials. The ceiling beams add an architectural charm, suggesting the home’s historic roots. The overall aesthetic combines functionality with a warm, inviting atmosphere, making it a cozy culinary space despite signs of wear and tear.

Bathroom

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This bathroom features a functional layout with essential elements. A vintage-style white porcelain sink with chrome faucets complements a wooden toilet with a round lid. The wall is lined with warm wooden paneling that adds a rustic charm, while a light-colored upper cabinet provides practical storage. A square mirror reflects light and enhances the cozy atmosphere. The flooring showcases a retro-style tile pattern, integrating shades of brown that coordinate with the overall wooden theme. The space is simple yet inviting, ideal for a quaint, historic home ambiance, focusing on utility without compromising aesthetic comfort.

Sunroom

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This sunroom showcases a cozy yet rustic aesthetic, featuring three wooden chairs, one being a classic rocking chair. The light floor contrasts with the dark wooden furniture, including a tall china cabinet and a vintage trunk, enhancing a timeless charm. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, accented by dark wooden trim that complements the overall color scheme. The walls are kept neutral, creating a serene backdrop for the furniture and maintaining an airy feel. Exposed wooden flooring hints at history, contributing to the inviting atmosphere ideal for relaxation or casual gatherings.

Living Room

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

This living room features a traditional layout centered around a classic brick fireplace, which adds warmth and character. The fireplace is flanked by wooden paneling, enhancing a rustic aesthetic. Dark wooden floors run throughout, complementing the rich tones of the furniture, including a mixture of antique chairs and side tables. A tall cabinet stands against one wall, showcasing intricate craftsmanship and a glass-front design. Light enters through windows with soft curtains, creating a cozy ambiance. The room’s overall color palette includes earthy browns and warm neutrals, providing a welcoming and nostalgic atmosphere.

Bathroom

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The bathroom features a unique blend of textures and patterns. A clawfoot bathtub is positioned against one wall, surrounded by a striking stone mosaic encompassing various shades of gray and black, exuding a vintage charm. Opposite, a white toilet integrates seamlessly with the pastel-colored wooden paneling that covers lower wall sections. A narrow window with striped curtains allows natural light to filter in, brightening the space. The flooring comprises small, reddish-brown tiles, contrasting with the stone walls. Overall, the combination of elements creates a cozy, eclectic atmosphere with a hint of old-world comfort.

Entryway

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The entryway features a classic staircase with a curved design, showcasing wooden railings alongside plush carpeting that adds warmth. Natural light filters through a sizeable window, illuminating a blend of vintage aesthetics and rustic charm. The walls are painted white, serving as a neutral backdrop against rich wooden accents, including a large cabinet and a side table. Beneath, wide hardwood flooring exhibits a timeworn character. Nearby, a vintage radiator signals the home’s historical heating system. The open layout allows easy movement, while the inviting atmosphere hints at classic American architecture harmonized with cozy furnishings.

Loft Space

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

A spacious loft area features a striking sloped ceiling with a textured finish. Natural light streams through large windows adorned with soft, flowing curtains, enhancing the openness of the room. The wooden flooring showcases rich tones, contributing warmth to the space, and complements the wooden railing along the staircase leading downstairs. A low-profile, wicker seating area adds a touch of vintage charm, with a cozy atmosphere created by the proximity to nature outside. The light color of the walls, contrasting with the darker wooden elements, emphasizes a clean and airy aesthetic, perfect for relaxation or creative pursuits.

Bathroom Details

Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate

The bathroom features an angled ceiling typical of an attic space, creating a quaint, cozy atmosphere. Wood paneling along the lower half of the walls adds warmth, contrasting with the white upper section. A classic tub is installed beside the wall, showcasing vintage chrome fixtures. Opposite, a pedestal sink complements a traditional toilet, both in a porcelain white finish, enhancing the clean aesthetic. Soft brown carpet covers the floor, adding a touch of comfort. Natural light streams in through a window adorned with wooden shutters, providing a quaint view and enriching the overall charming feel of this historic home.

Listing Agent: Peggy Witt of Lake Naomi Real Estate via Zillow 

Leave a Comment