Nestled in Hayward, WI, Spider Lake Lodge is a historic gem built in 1923, now listed on the National Register of Historic Places. This log cabin-style masterpiece underwent significant renovations starting in 2018, enhancing its structural integrity, adding a new roof, and upgrading mechanical systems while preserving its vintage charm. It boasts 9 guest rooms, 11 bathrooms, and 8 fireplaces, set on a plot that shares access to beautiful sandy beaches via the Moody’s Association. The property includes a detached 1,260 sq ft garage with a guest suite, perfect for rentals. Priced at $1,695,000, this versatile property combines historic allure with modern comforts across a generous total square footage.
Lodge Entrance
A rustic lodge entrance framed by tall, lush trees evokes a serene atmosphere. The gravel road leads towards a grassy clearing, welcoming visitors to Spider Lake Lodge, established in 1923. Prominently featured is a wooden sign displaying the lodge’s name, crafted from natural materials that harmonize with the surroundings. Nearby, simple picnic tables are visible, inviting outdoor leisure. The architecture of the lodge in the background hints at a traditional cabin style, with a muted color palette that blends into the natural landscape, enhancing the tranquil, wooded setting. Sunlight filters through the trees, adding warmth.
Lakeside View
A serene lakeside setting features a sandy shore lined with lush greenery and tall trees. Wooden Adirondack chairs provide a cozy spot to relax, facing the calm waters. A red boat rests on a dock, complemented by gentle ripples reflecting the blue sky above, dotted with white clouds. The landscape is framed by dense foliage, creating a tranquil and inviting atmosphere. Pathways lead to the water, enhancing accessibility to both the dock and the beach area. The harmonious blend of nature and thoughtful seating arrangements invites leisure and contemplation in this outdoor oasis.
Waterfront Retreat
A serene lakeside area features a wooden dock extending into calm water, flanked by lush greenery. Adirondack chairs in muted colors create a cozy gathering spot near the shoreline. A few canoes and kayaks rest on the grass, inviting outdoor adventures. Tall trees provide a natural canopy, casting dappled sunlight across the landscape. A gentle slope leads up to a rustic pathway, lined with wooden railings, guiding visitors through the natural foliage. The overall aesthetic is tranquil and inviting, offering a perfect blend of relaxation and nature exploration, ideal for enjoying sunny afternoons by the water.
Living Room
This cozy living room features a warm, rustic aesthetic with exposed wooden beams and log cabin architecture. The ceiling is a rich wood tone that complements the natural stone fireplace, adorned with a mounted moose head, enhancing the cabin feel. A plush, dark green sofa is accented by colorful throw pillows, arranged with an elegant coffee table in front. The rich red patterned rug adds a pop of color to the wooden floor. Large windows allow abundant light, framed by flowing red drapes, while antique lamps provide soft illumination, making this space inviting and perfect for relaxation.
Living Room
This living room showcases a rustic charm with exposed wooden beams and a vaulted ceiling. The walls feature a warm, natural finish that complements the wooden floor. A central stone fireplace, surrounded by comfortable seating in rich tones, becomes the focal point. A wooden dining table, adorned with rustic decor, invites gatherings. Natural light floods in from large windows, highlighting cozy corners decorated with lamps and books. The color palette combines earthy browns with hints of red from throw pillows and rugs, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that encourages relaxation and connection.
Living Room
The living room features a rustic log cabin aesthetic with a soaring wooden ceiling and exposed beams. Rich brown tones dominate the space, complemented by natural stone details on the grand fireplace, which serves as a focal point. Warm lighting fixtures add a cozy ambiance. Various seating arrangements include plush armchairs adorned with plaid patterns, inviting guests to relax. A wooden table mixed with antique decor pieces showcases the room’s character. The walls are decorated with art and vintage hats, while large windows framed by burgundy curtains offer views of the surrounding landscape, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.
Living Room
This living room features a rustic design with dark wood paneling and beams creating a cozy atmosphere. A prominent stone fireplace, adorned with animal mounts, acts as a focal point. Deep red curtains complement the wooden elements, while various seating options, including leather chairs and a large fabric sofa with a striking pattern, offer comfort. A patterned area rug grounds the space, juxtaposing the smooth wooden floors. A small side table with a lamp and quaint decorations adds charm, while large windows allow natural light to flood the area, highlighting the warmth of the wood and creating an inviting ambiance.
Living Room
This rustic living room features exposed wooden beams and a sloped ceiling, enhancing its log cabin aesthetic. The walls are adorned with horizontal wooden panels, providing a warm, natural texture. A plush, dark green sofa and a tufted leather ottoman create a cozy seating area, accented by decorative pillows. A traditional red and black patterned rug anchors the space, while large windows allow natural light to flood in, showcasing surrounding greenery. Decorative elements include a bear skin mounted on the wall, vintage lamps, and handcrafted wooden furniture, infusing the room with character and a homely atmosphere.
Sunroom
A rustic sunroom featuring a wooden ceiling and large windows that invite natural light and provide expansive views of surrounding trees. The warm wood tones create a cozy atmosphere. Furnished with wicker seating and an eclectic coffee table, the space has a casual charm. A bright green area rug with a geometric border adds a pop of color against the dark wooden floor. An upright coat rack stands in the corner, suggesting practicality. The overall design emphasizes a connection with nature, perfect for relaxation or social gatherings, enhancing its inviting and serene character.
Sunroom
This sunroom features a warm, rustic aesthetic with wood-paneled walls and a sloped wooden ceiling that enhances the cozy atmosphere. Large windows wrap around, allowing natural light to flood the space while providing stunning views of the surrounding greenery. A wicker sofa adorned with plush cushions serves as the main seating area, complemented by a small wooden table in front. A patterned armchair adds a touch of color, creating a welcoming seating arrangement. The contrasting green trim on the windows adds a charming detail. The overall atmosphere feels inviting, perfect for relaxation or social gatherings.
Sunroom Space
This sunroom features a warm, rustic charm with its rich, wooden ceiling that complements the cozy atmosphere. Large windows adorned with teal frames allow ample natural light, while offering views of the surrounding greenery. A comfortable sofa, covered in a mix of patterned cushions, invites relaxation. Adjacent, a simple wicker chair and a small wooden table enhance the seating area. The floor is adorned with a soft, turquoise rug bordered by a white pattern. Items like a Coca-Cola cooler and wall decorations embody a vintage aesthetic, while the overall layout encourages an inviting communal space for leisure.
Great Room
This spacious great room features a stunning open layout with vaulted ceilings, showcasing intricate wood beams and logs that emphasize a rustic charm. Rich, warm wood tones dominate the space, beautifully complemented by large windows that invite abundant natural light and offer scenic views of the outdoors. The room is tastefully furnished with a mix of cozy armchairs and a stylish sectional, arranged around a central round table. A striking antler chandelier hangs overhead, adding a touch of elegance. Decorative elements, like patterned rugs and tasteful floral arrangements, enhance the inviting atmosphere, making it perfect for gathering.
Living Room
The spacious living room features a charming rustic design, highlighted by wooden beams and a stone fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Rich browns dominate the color palette, complemented by vibrant accents on rugs and upholstered furniture. Plush sofas in muted tones are paired with wooden chairs, while intricate patterns on the area rug add cultural depth. Large windows allow ample natural light, framing views of the surrounding greenery. Decorative elements, such as mounted antlers and a vintage chandelier, enhance the lodge-like feel, seamlessly blending comfort with an authentic outdoor aesthetic.
Living Room
A cozy living room showcasing rustic charm with log cabin walls and a pitched ceiling. The stone fireplace serves as a focal point, adorned with a mounted deer head and various artifacts. Natural light filters through large windows, accentuating warm wood tones and earthy textures. Furnishings include a plush leather sofa in ochre, a pink upholstered chair, and woven seating, arranged for comfort. A vibrant area rug adds colorful contrast, harmonizing with the natural decor. The open doorway leads to a rustic kitchen area, enhancing the communal atmosphere of this inviting space.
Dining Area
This cozy dining area features rustic charm with exposed wooden beams and log walls. A granite countertop acts as a service area, accompanied by traditional wooden cabinetry. The color palette includes rich browns and warm wooden tones, creating an inviting atmosphere. A playful sign hangs above, adding character to the space, while sunlight filters through a glass door, illuminating the area. The floor is adorned with a classic checkered rug, enhancing the country-style decor. Nearby, a nostalgic beverage display emphasizes the historical elements, blending comfort with functionality in this warm gathering spot.
Great Room
This spacious great room features a vaulted ceiling adorned with wooden beams, enhancing the rustic charm. The warm wood accents create a cozy atmosphere, complemented by rich, brown tones throughout. Plush seating, including a patterned love seat and matching armchairs, invites relaxation. A large coffee table sits atop a vibrant area rug with native motifs. The dining area showcases dark wooden chairs with plaid upholstery, set around a sturdy table. Natural light floods the space through expansive windows, providing views of nature. Suspended lights add elegance, while potted plants bring a touch of greenery indoors.
Dining Room
A cozy dining room featuring an abundance of natural light streaming through large windows, showcasing a stunning view of the outdoors. The ceiling is adorned with exposed wooden beams, complemented by wooden paneling on the walls and floor, creating a warm, rustic atmosphere. Several wooden tables and chairs with a simple design are positioned throughout the space, inviting gatherings and meals. A tasteful lamp sits on a side table, adding a soft glow to the room. The overall color scheme is warm, utilizing earthy tones and natural textures that enhance the inviting ambiance of this rustic setting.
Great Room
This spacious great room features high, vaulted ceilings with exposed wooden beams, lending a rustic charm. A stone fireplace serves as the focal point, surrounded by natural wood accents and vintage decor. The warm color palette includes rich browns of the logs and light wood flooring, enhancing the cozy atmosphere. Comfortable seating arrangements are made with plush armchairs and patterned rugs that add texture. A large chandelier hangs above, illuminating the space while decorative pieces on shelves and tables add character. The layout promotes social interaction, making it an inviting area for gatherings.
Kitchen Details
This spacious kitchen features a warm, rustic aesthetic with wooden beams and a rich wood-paneled ceiling. The floors are gleaming hardwood, complementing the earthy tones of the cabinetry. An island stands centrally, equipped with a stainless-steel countertop and storage underneath. Various cooking appliances, including a vintage stove and modern oven, line the walls. Shelving displays an array of kitchen tools and decorative items. Light floods through multiple windows, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. The combination of vintage and contemporary elements creates a unique blend, showcasing the kitchen as a functional yet charming heart of the home.
Kitchen Area
This kitchen showcases rustic charm with its warm wood paneling and sloped ceiling beams. The countertops are a speckled granite, contrasting beautifully with the natural wood cabinetry. A double sink sits beneath a wide window, inviting ample natural light and offering a view of lush greenery outside. The layout features a combination of functional appliances, including a fan and a coffee maker, alongside neatly arranged plates in open shelving. A dark runner rug adds a touch of coziness, while the overall neutral color palette emphasizes a welcoming, homey atmosphere, perfect for cooking and gathering.
Bedroom
This rustic bedroom features warm wooden walls and a vaulted ceiling that enhances its inviting atmosphere. A black wrought-iron bed with a decorative headboard occupies the center, adorned with red accent pillows that pop against the white bedding. Natural light floods in through multiple windows adorned with wooden blinds, emphasizing the room’s earthy tones. A cozy woven rug adds texture while a simple bedside table holds a lamp, maintaining the room’s understated elegance. The wooden beams and logs create a connection to nature, while an armchair in the corner invites relaxation, enhancing the room’s overall homey feel.
Bedroom
This cozy bedroom features rustic log walls and a warm ambiance. The color palette consists of browns and earthy tones, enhancing the natural wood feel. A plaid bedspread adds a touch of comfort against the wooden bed frame. A small decorative stove positioned near the foot of the bed contributes both warmth and a nostalgic charm. Two distinct seating areas include a cushioned chair and a small table, perfect for relaxation. Sunlight filters through the wooden-framed windows, casting a soft glow, while vintage artwork on the walls enriches the historic character of the space.
Entryway
This cozy entryway features natural wood finishes, with a warm tone from the wooden planks on the ceiling and walls. The floor displays rich, dark hardwood, complementing the inviting ambiance. A rustic sign hangs on the wall, reading ‘Spider Lake Lodge’, adding charm. To the left, a plush sofa sits near large windows, enhancing natural light. The space showcases a small round wooden table with tall stools, perfect for casual gatherings. Adjacent, a teal accent table stands with decorative items. Simple wall sconces illuminate the area, lending a comfortable, cabin-like feel to the home.
Game Room
This game room features a rustic charm with warm wooden tones dominating the design. The room is adorned with polished wooden walls and ceiling, creating a cozy, cabin-like atmosphere. A stylish billiards table, draped in teal felt, serves as the centerpiece, complemented by elegant antler chandeliers that enhance the space’s ambiance. Plush leather sofas invite relaxation, while sturdy wooden chairs add functionality. Large windows bring in natural light, surrounded by natural scenery. The floor is covered with rich, dark wood, adding depth to the room. Architectural details such as columns and wall sconces add sophistication and warmth.
Living Room
A cozy living room showcases a warm, rustic design with wooden paneling throughout. The ceiling features vertical planks that extend down the walls, creating an inviting atmosphere. Rich, medium-brown leather sofas are positioned comfortably around a central wooden coffee table, enhancing the room’s warmth. Large windows allow natural light to flood in, framed by simple blinds, while scenic views of the outdoors are visible. Decorative elements include subtle nautical-themed accents, like oars, and a chandelier resembling antlers, adding character. Nearby, light wooden chairs provide additional seating, ensuring a relaxed, homely feel perfect for gatherings.
Living Room
This cozy living room features a rustic wood aesthetic with warm wooden beams and a paneled ceiling that creates an inviting atmosphere. The floor is a rich hardwood, complementing the natural tones throughout. A stone fireplace serves as a focal point, surrounded by comfortable seating including a dark plush couch and a wicker chair. Large windows allow ample natural light, enhanced by adjacent lamp fixtures. A canoe hangs above a bar area with wooden stools, seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor themes. The decor is minimal yet functional, providing a perfect setting for relaxation and gatherings.
Living Room
This living room features warm wooden paneling and a cozy layout. A canoe suspended above adds a distinct character, reflecting a nautical theme. The floor is made of polished hardwood, enhancing the rustic ambience. Two plush, dark-colored armchairs sit comfortably alongside a tufted ottoman, creating an inviting seating area. A sofa draped with a throw is sprinkled with plaid cushions, offering a casual touch. Wall art, including framed prints, adds visual interest, accentuated by natural light filtering through windows. A sleek media console houses a television, blending modern elements with the space’s historical charm.
Bedroom
A cozy bedroom featuring warm wooden paneling that creates an inviting atmosphere. The room centers around a rustic log bed adorned with a patterned blanket, showcasing a nature theme with moose graphics. Beside the bed, a modern lamp provides soft lighting. Two plush white robes hang on hooks near the entrance, emphasizing relaxation. The flooring is dark wood, contrasting with the lighter wood walls. A piece of art hangs on one wall, depicting colorful trees, adding a splash of visual interest. A ceiling fan circulates air, enhancing comfort in this serene, cabin-like retreat.
Living Room
This cozy living room features a warm, inviting layout with natural wood elements and a soft color palette. The dual seating arrangement comprises a patterned sofa and rustic armchairs made of light wood, enhancing the room’s cabin-like feel. A large wooden coffee table sits center stage, complementing the wooden flooring. The walls are painted in a muted beige, creating a calm backdrop for the space. An overhead ceiling fan circulates air, while recessed lighting adds brightness. In the back, an open kitchen layout is visible with light-colored cabinetry, contributing to the overall spaciousness and modern aesthetic.
Bedroom
Cozy bedroom featuring a rustic aesthetic with natural wood elements. The large wooden bed showcases a log-style frame, topped with a blue and white plaid comforter and decorative pillows. A matching wooden nightstand with a lamp and a small drawer sits beside the bed, adding functionality. Natural light floods the room through a sizable window, framed with light wood trim, providing a view of greenery outside. The walls are painted in a soft beige, complementing the warm tones of the hardwood floor. A mirror above the nightstand reflects the room’s warmth while enhancing its spacious feel.
Listing Agent: Michael Lynch of Lakes Sotheby’s International Realty via Zillow
